Education11/25/2025
How to Spot a Fake: Your Practical Guide to Authentic Gemstones (What to Look For & When to Seek an Expert)

The Honest Truth: Most Gems Aren't "Perfect"
Before diving in, remember: perfectly flawless gemstones are incredibly rare and expensive. Many genuine stones have natural inclusions (tiny imperfections) or have undergone standard treatments (like heating) to enhance their color. These don't necessarily make them "fake," but understanding them is key.
1. The "Too Perfect" Red Flag
What to Look For:
- If a large, unblemished gemstone with vibrant color is being sold at a suspiciously low price, be very wary.
- Flawless clarity and intense color in large sizes usually come with a hefty price tag.
Why it's a Sign:
- It's often glass, plastic, or a laboratory-grown stone being misrepresented.
2. Uneven Color and Air Bubbles
What to Look For:
- Examine the stone closely under good lighting.
- Do you see tiny, perfectly round air bubbles inside?
- Is the color concentrated in certain areas or streaky?
Why it's a Sign:
- Air bubbles are a classic indicator of glass.
- Uneven color can sometimes point to dyed stones or composites.
3. Hardness Test (Use with Caution!)
What to Look For:
- If you have a known genuine stone of a certain hardness (e.g., Quartz, Mohs 7), you can very gently try to scratch the unknown stone in an inconspicuous area.
- If it scratches easily, it's softer than the known stone.
Why it's a Sign:
- This is a basic indicator. A stone that scratches easily is unlikely to be a Sapphire (Mohs 9) or Emerald (Mohs 7.5-8), for instance.
- Disclaimer: Only attempt this if you know what you're doing, as you can damage the stone!
4. Temperature and Fogging Test
What to Look For:
- Hold the stone between your fingers for a few seconds, then immediately breathe on it to fog it up.
- How quickly does the fog dissipate?
Why it's a Sign:
- Genuine, natural stones (especially diamonds) dissipate fog much faster than glass or plastic, as they are poorer conductors of heat.
When to See a Professional
For high-value gems or if you're ever in doubt, always consult a certified gemologist.
They have specialized tools (like refractometers and microscopes) to accurately identify a stone's properties without damaging it.
It's an investment in peace of mind.